In the spring of 2019, James Loney acquired Sticky Fingers from its previous owners with the intent of selling the same superb ice creams but also widening the storefront's offerings to include great and nutritious lunches. We still sell wonderful and amazing ice creams but have now also opened "SoupySoup@Sticky Fingers Delectables"--our soup and stew factory for our local community. We provide you with a reasonably-priced, totally DELICIOUS, nutritious, and ever-changing menu of lunchtime slurpables. Soups and stews are made daily with the freshest ingredients, home-made bases, broths and stocks, and served ready-to-go with or without yummy Beach Lake Bakery rolls (plain, buttered, or garlicky-buttered). Swing on by and try us out. Vegetarian / vegan / and meat-based options are available! See you soon!
The ice creams and sorbets we sell at Sticky Fingers are made by Jane’s Ice Cream of Kingston, NY. Jane's uses the best hormone-free milk from New York State cows and only the finest natural and local ingredients to flavor their ice creams. With no artificial flavors or colors and only plant-based stabilizers, you can rest assured that Jane’s tasty confections live up to your quality and taste bud standards. All flavors, except those containing the words "cookie," "cake," "pretzel," or "dough," are gluten free. All of the sorbets are completely dairy-free and made with simple de-seeded and de-fibred whole fruit. All flavors are egg free. Worried about nuts? Jane’s produces all of their nut flavors at the end of the day, after which all machinery is broken down and sanitized for the next day. If someone in your party has a nut allergy, please inform the server/manager and that member of your party will be served first.
Hello Kind and Gentle People living in the Empire of Ice Cream!
Many of you have asked us to post a menu before you head over Horseshoe Lake Road-way to Sticky Fingers Delectables.
We are happy to oblige. Swing on by and enjoy our delectable ice creams on the shores of sparkling Kauneonga or under the broad timbered awning of our 200 year old Pavilion..
Here's a listing of the flavors we generally keep stocked at all times. Please note that our vegan flavors often change from week to week; call or text us ahead of your visit and we'll give you the latest on what's available.
All the best and here's to a wondrous and sumptuous summer of laughter and reawakenings!
Apricot Orange Blossom
Coconut* Almond Joy
Cappuccino Kahlua Calypso
Cinnamon Crumb Cake^
Cookies & Cream^
Dulce de Luce
Peanut* Butter Fudge
Salted Caramel Pretzel^
* Contains nuts
^ Contains gluten.
Please inform your server or the manager of any allergies.
Gluten-free cones, home-made whipped cream, sprinkles (rainbow, chocolate, Sticky Fingers Blue), home-made French hot fudge, crushed walnuts are also generally available.
Thank you and see you soon!
~ James and the Sticky Fingers Gang
Sign up to hear from us about discounts, new items being added to our menu, & community special events.